Is it permitted to go shopping on Chol Hamoed?

Home Cyber Torah Subscribe More▼

A Scholar is currently unavailable at this time, so please check back again. In the meantime you can click here to email Moses your question or search our archives for related topics.

Why is the bastard child punished for the parents' sins?

Library » Intimacy » Reproductive Issues | Subscribe | What is RSS?

PRINT EMAIL COMMENT

Rabbi Shlomo Chein: Welcome. I'll be with you in a moment...what's on your mind?

GTM: In relation to a Mamzer [Ed. note: See What is the legal definition of a "mamzer"], why is the child punished for the parents sins?

Rabbi Shlomo Chein: that is a good question. The answer is the child is NOT punished! The child merely suffers a consequence. It is like asking why is a child "punished" for the foolishness of the mother smoking or taking drugs? Obviously the child is not "punished" rather it suffers the consequence of the action

Rabbi Shlomo Chein: so to with a Mamzer - the parents are punished! There are punishments for their action. The child is merely a consequence of their wrong deed

GTM: ooo thank you

Rabbi Shlomo Chein: sure

All names, places, and identifying information have been changed or deleted in order to protect the privacy of the questioners. In order to preserve authenticity, the chat sessions have been posted with a minimum of editing. Please excuse typographical errors, missing punctuation, and/or grammatical mistakes which naturally occur in the course of informal chat sessions.

ADD A COMMENT

Please email me when new comments are posted (you must be logged in).

COMMENTS

why is a child mamzer punished for their parents sin?

Posted by: Scheins, Brooklyn, NY on Aug 30, 2005

I dont think that your alagory is correct and i dont feel like you answered the question. if a child from a parent who takes drugs Chalila, is born. it is born with chalila a defect. where as a mamzer child is not born with a defect. it is not until the child is older and getting married that the child is punished with this "defect" only being allowed to marry another mamzer. and the child knows that he cant marry anyone else whereas the child born with a defect does not know any different.

Editor's Comment

The mamzer also has a defect -- a spiritual one. That is why he or she cannot intermarry with a "regular" Jew.

Posted by: B. on Jan 18, 2006

If the mother smokes while pregnant, logically the child should not have to bear the consequences. Or, in talmudic terms, if a man steals a seed and plants it, by all rights the seed should not grow, because it is stolen! But the world works along established ways, and those who abuse it will self destruct. G'd visits "wrath unto the 4th generation" not because He's mean, but because one who grows up with wicked parents is likely to be wicked oneself, and so on for about 4 generations until it fades out. Of course, you may just as well turn out to be a tzadik, which is even more credit to you.

RELATED CATEGORIES

Intimacy » Sexual Issues
Life Cycle » Birth » Reproductive Issues

Mamzer

A child who is the product of incest or adultery (i.e. a married woman with a man other than her husband). A mamzer may only marry another mamzer.

Why is the bastard child punished for the parents' sins?

Library » Intimacy » Reproductive Issues | Subscribe | What is RSS?

COMMENTS

why is a child mamzer punished for their parents sin?

Posted by: Scheins, Brooklyn, NY on Aug 30, 2005

the mamzer

Posted by: B. on Jan 18, 2006

RELATED CATEGORIES

Email to a friend

Post a comment

Holidays - Torah - Philosophy - G-d - Jewish Identity - Mitzvot - Chassidism - Daily Life - Shabbat - Life Cycle - Intimacy - Women & Judaism - History - Israel - Miscellaneous - Best of AskMoses