| Is praying at a gravesite like idolatry? |
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
|
A Scholar is currently unavailable at this time, so please check back again. In the meantime you can click here to email Moses your question or search our archives for related topics.
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
|
Jewish Astrology?by Rabbi Moshe Wisnefsky
Footnotes
COMMENTSRELATED CATEGORIESMiscellaneous » The Jewish Calendar
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Home |
Mission Statement |
Contact |
Add Ask Moses To Your Site |
Press Releases |
Reviews |
Privacy Policy |
Support Ask Moses |
Moses Store
AskMoses.com © 2012
Kosher Astrology
Posted by: Evelyn Goodman, Los Angeles, CA on May 22, 2005
I am simply amazed
Editor's Comment
It's all a matter of semantics. Judaism is in general opposed to "astrology" because the practice that goes by that name today is a corruption of the original astrology as taught in the Torah. Today's astrology definitely falls under the prohibition of "None of you shall be...soothsayers...for all these are an abomination to G-d, and because of these abominations G-d is expelling [the nations that practice them] before you. Rather, you should be ingenuous with G-d, your G-d" (Deuteronomy 18:10-13). Rashi explains the word "ingenuous" ("tamim") as follows: "Relate to Him simply, depend on Him, do not try to second-guess the future. Rather, receive whatever happens to you wholesomely; then you will be with Him and one of His." An excellent book describing which practices are permitted and which forbidden by the Torah is "Faith and Folly" by Rabbi Yaakov Hillel (published by Yeshivat Hevrat Ahavat Shalom, Jerusalem 1990, distributed by Feldheim).
The point of Jewish astrology is not to predict the future or suggest behavior based on the signs of heaven. Judaism teaches us that if we are connected to the Torah, which is above nature, we need not concern ourselves with the forces of nature such as the influence of the zodiac.
Rather, the purpose of Jewish astrology is to help us understand ourselves and give us direction on how to work on ourselves.
Whereas today's astrology seems to be oriented toward ascertaining the forces operating in the world in order to figure out how to get around them or capitalize on them, i.e., to work with or around the forces in the world for our benefit -- and thereby make it less necessary or wholly unnecessary to obtain Divine favor by good behavior and following His will, Jewish astrology seeks to understand the energies G-d put in the world in order to utilize these to *better* do His will, as a way of understanding ourselves and the gifts G-d put at our disposal to develop ourselves, mature, and grow spiritually, all the intent to cling to Him and do His will more joyfully, fully, etc.
Jewish "Astrology"
Posted by: Anonymous, Providence, RI on Aug 08, 2005
Evelyn, Judaism has always recognised auspicious times for different qualities and events. I think that while Moshe is relating this to "astrology", it has nothing at all to do with "astrology". We are expressly forbidden to engage in astrology (Greco-Roman at that). Jewish months have *nothing* to do with the positions of constellations and planets. The Gregorian calendar can be related to astrological "sun signs", as it is based on the rotation of the Earth around the Sun. The Jewish calendar is based on the Moon's rotation around the Earth with leap years to keep the three festivals in the correct seasons (which is a solar quality).
Kabbalistically, we know that certain times are connected with different qualities. For example, the three weeks leading up to Tisha B'Av, especially Av 1 to Av 9, is a bad time for Jews to travel, have surgery, make life decisions, etc. On the other hand, Adar is the best time for a Jew to make himself available in a legal battle with a Non-Jew.
Editor's Comment
Kabbalistic Astrology
Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 07, 2005
Clarification
Posted by: Ben, Nashville, TN, USA on Sep 29, 2005
There is Eastern, Vedic, Western, Horary, Mundane and Natal, etc. All with very different schools of thought.
What type of astrology would the Torah align with? Which is the most orthodox?
Editor's Comment
I'm not familiar with any of these, but I would wager that the Torah would not align with any of them, inasmuch as every type of astrological practice I've ever heard of is a corruption of the Torah's system. Like many (if not all) other spiritual practices and religions, astrology in its various forms as known today originated thousands of years ago with the knowledge G-d gave to the ancients (perhaps to Adam, or if not, to Abraham) and which became perverted when people's approach to spirituality shifted from "how can I get close to G-d" to "how can I get what I want from G-d" or "how can I access supernatural powers without having to commit myself to a G-dly lifestyle."
What about Levi?
Posted by: Anonymous on Dec 11, 2005
Editor's Comment
books
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 11, 2006
Editor's Comment
Astrology
Posted by: x ben x on Nov 23, 2006
The problem is that in day to day speech, we rarely note a difference between false astrology, such as those columns in newspapers, etc., and true astrology, the goal of which is to help to show us areas of ourselves which we need to correct.
Shana Tova,
Miracles and Wonders